We pride ourselves on being the shop with integrity—the shop you can trust.

We make a habit of working with people and helping in every way we can. Whether that's insurance claims, deductibles, passing inspection, or anywhere else.

We do things other shops won't, and we take great joy in being a part of your trusted family.


Allstar Automotive has been in business since 1999, though its roots go back to the 1920's.

In 1925 it began as Midgley's Body Shop and was located in downtown Salt Lake City on Broadway (300 south) in what was called the Broadway Garages. From there, the second generation Midgley moved the shop to Jefferson Street in the late 1940's.

In 1952 a young Idaho farm boy, just back from a tour of duty in Korea, moved to Salt Lake and took some courses in auto body repair. He was hired right out of school by Chet Midgley who owned Midgley's Body Shop—this young man was Doyle Lloyd.

Doyle worked for Midgley's until 1965 when he bought the shop in its current location, 1191 South 300 West in Salt Lake and changed the name to Doyle's Body Shop.

In the 1990's Doyle hired a hard working young man named Darin Tall, and in 1999 Darin bought the business from Doyle. He changed the name to Allstar Automotive, which it remains to this day.

After many years of change (equipment upgrades and building improvements), this body shop still takes pride in everything of yours that we work on. We love to work on cars but we love people even more. We have a strong customer base that began generations ago and these customers have become our friends and family. We have always offered honest and quality work at a fair price, and will continue to do so as long as our doors are open.


Allstar Automotive has been committed to excellence since 1999. Our staff has well over 100 years of combined experience—you're in good hands.

When Angi's List became popular Allstar Auto was proud to receive awards from them for 5 years in a row—it was our main source for reviews and promotion, beyond word-of-mouth.

Eventually, Angi's list was bought out and transformed into something else. We lost many wonderful, heart-felt reviews that were very special to us.

Thank you for all of you who had taken time out of your day to submit a review on that platform (and any other platform). You have not been forgotten, and we appreciate your contribution to this small business.